Back in mid-November, Major League Soccer announced that they are going to change the schedule of the league. Ever since its inception in 1996, they started play some time in the spring (in '96 it was April; now it begins late February or early March) and ends some time in early December. But this Year, the 30th Year of MLS, will be the last under this calendar year format. After playing a four-month "spring season" in the spring of 2027, MLS will align its year with pretty much every soccer league in every country on Earth, where they start late summer and end around Memorial Weekend.
Not too long ago, I heard the Commissioner for MLS say that he didn't think that would be a good idea, and I think his main reason was that so many northern cities (such as Minnesota United) would be affected by figuring out how to deal with a part of the summer-to-spring season that makes outdoor Matches well nigh impossible to stage in the winter. Guess he changed his mind, and I guess that not sticking out like an outlier, especially when it comes to trying to bring in players through Transfer Windows that are, right now, a bit awkward, was enough of a reason to do this wholesale change.
At first blush, I hate this as a season-ticket holder. The idea that players didn't want to join a club in MLS during the middle of our season or the middle of the season of the league they're coming from is still too abstract for me to care about. But another plus the Commissioner claimed would make the new calendar better is that Major League Soccer would get away from having its postseason run right into the National Football League and college football. True -- and I still don't think it's a good enough reason to do, as some people are calling it, "The Flip." Yes, football (mostly professional but college matters too) is the most popular sport in the country. But it's their regular season; MLS has conducted its postseason late in the fall. I will go to lengths to see a postseason Loons Match in person (I have skipped out on Game-watching events in the past) because they are the most important Matches on the schedule, and I think diehard fans of other MLS squads have done and would do the same.
Conversely, the commish also says that putting MLS' playoffs in May is a lot less crowded. No, it isn't. The NBA Playoffs and The NHL Stanley Cup Playoffs are also played in May. Basketball and hockey are not the behemoth that American football is. But you cannot convince me that soccer has a chance to stick out and rise above the din at a time those two leagues also have their postseasons. When the Games matter most, MLS will take a backseat to both the NBA and NHL, every Year. (And hell, to be honest with you, the NHL takes a backseat to the NBA every May, too.) Major League Soccer is not running from a crowded part of the year; it's running to a crowded part of the year. And I don't think it's going to work. So on second blush, I still hate this.
Another point I considered: I thought that there would be Matches played through the winter, and we would thus have to have a few or even several of them played during the holidays. Then MLS announced that there will be an annual two-Month Winter Break from mid-December to mid-February, and then on top of that there will be special considerations to limit the number of Games played here in December and February to one or two.
But I decided to think further. What about this Winter Break? It's good for the safety of players and fans, no doubt. But what sports league do you know builds in a two-Month break in its season? Wouldn't that feel like two separate seasons? And what happens if, for example, MNUFC just sucks for the first part of the Year? Would anyone want to come back and see the final part of the season if the Loons blow? (Major League Soccer anticipates that 2/3 of the season is completed before Winter Break and the final third is completed once play resumes and into the end of April, which is supposed to be when the regular season will end.) This has the potential to be a momentum killer.
Another point of concern comes in the fall. I am very busy during American football season. I work Vikings and Golden Gophers Games, and I organize Game-watching parties for my alma mater. These conflicts have been in place since Minnesota United started MLS play in 2017, so it's nothing new. Still, it's a pain in the ass to, for example, wait for when my alma mater announces the time of their Game in two Weeks and figure out whether I could travel from downtown Minneapolis to Midway to see my Loons, or if it's worth it to catch only the Second Half of the MNUFC Match, or if I need to sell my ticket. Usually, one to three of my season tickets are casualties to these circumstances each year.
The announcement didn't say, but I wonder, assuming there will be at least as many Matches in a regular season as there currently are now, if there will be more Matches played in the fall. So I have looked at the upcoming season, looked through my Franklin Quests for the past few years, and jotted down how many autumn Matches there have been from 2022 to this season, which would be ones subject to either work or play conflicts due to American football.
2026 home Games in the fall I have to worry about skipping: 5
2025: 3
2024: 3
2023: 4
2022: 1
There are tons of caveats here. Major League Soccer has frequently shifted their seasons, and put in breaks during the middle of them, if there have been other worldwide soccer conflicts, such as the World Cup and continental tournaments, so there will be years more Matches had to be piled into the autumn. Also, I wanted to go back all the way to 2017, but I realized that 2021 and 2020 were severely impacted by the pandemic -- I couldn't go at all in 2020, and I think I started going to Games late in the summer of 2021 -- and so it didn't make sense to go back even further. Finally, we don't have the 2027-8 schedule out yet, of course, so we don't know if there will be a concentration of Matches in the fall. Still, while I have no evidence this will get worse under the new calendar, I will go with my gut and believe it will be.
But I realized something further. It may not be the fall that impacts my season-ticket status the most, but the summer. Major League Soccer says it'll conduct its postseason in May, and the league will begin its new season in mid-July. Assuming MNUFC won't host Games for the playoffs or even make the playoffs (and I would contend that the league is rapidly creating a Haves/Have-nots hierarchy not unlike The English Premier League, and undoubtedly my Loons ain't gonna be a Have), there won't be Matches for me to go to between May and mid-July.
How many Matches have taken place in that time period? I went back through my FQs and checked:
2026 home Games between May (the scheduled month for postseason, which the Loons obviously are not guaranteed to play, let alone play any home Matches) and mid-July (the approximate start of the new season format): 3
2025: 6
2024: 6
2023: 6
2022: 5
More caveats here. The three Matches this season is because MLS needs to take a break for the World Cup. Also, Minnesota United FC salespeople have been trying to emphasize they are going to fill this hole with pre-season Matches and Friendlies against clubs from other countries, which should be easier once MLS' preseason aligns with so many other leagues' preseasons. But you can tell that it's not the same. I actually love going to Loons Games during the late spring and early summer. There's not much to do, the weather is heating up, and I have enjoyed many Matches with other Loons fans this time of Year.
And then I realized that this is the part of the season that I will miss, and that this is the reason why this new calendar sucks. And there is little to no chance that there will be any attempt that will be adequate to fill this hole. So now what? Well, first of all, because I care about the integrity of the season, I would like to suggest a split-season not unlike what Mexico's Liga MX does. Every Year they have, basically, two Years: An "Apertura" (opening) season that goes from July to just before the holidays, and a "Clausura" (closing) season that goes from early January to Memorial Weekend. OK, so you have two champions a Year. Big deal; that means there is no yawning two-Month gap in a season you're determined to say lasts ten Months. For this to happen, Major League Soccer would have to have only a one-Month break, and Minnesota United would probably have to play a few Matches in January and February. Would I watch them in person? Maybe, maybe not. But at least the season would make a whole lot more sense.
Beyond that, I don't know what to think. Well, I said a long time ago that unless I die, move, lose my job, or determine the organization has done something that so offends my moral code, I won't be dropping my season ticket. I didn't add some sort of force majeure clause when I declared that, but I sure as hell didn't think they'd do The Flip, either. So I think I'll give it a year, to see how many more Matches I might have to miss in the fall, and how many times from May to mid-July I'll be bored out of my skull because there's no important MNUFC Game to go to. If it doesn't make sense to spend money on a season ticket -- and that price keeps going up every Year -- maybe I'll be forced to downgrade my season ticket package ... or say goodbye.